We’ve seen all the outward manifestations of cult loyalty: The truck wraps and the Trump neck tattoos. The rural rallies and the Mar-a-Lago fêtes. The faux piety and the very real violence and threats of retribution. The idealized images blended with the fascist symbols of the past.
An election in which Trump was barely able to eke out a win may have been enough to return the convicted felon to the Oval Office instead of a prison cell. But the margin of victory was narrow. Trump managed to get only a measly 1.5% more of the votes than Harris — a plurality but not a majority.
Trump — 77,303,573 votes (49.9%)
Harris — 75,019,257 votes (48.4%)
That’s hardly the landslide that he has been claiming since Election Day and, no, they’re not still counting the votes, as he claimed in his off-the-wall press conference earlier this week.
So what happens when the inevitable negative results of Trump’s policies and actions start to directly affect the true believers? Will the devotion shown to their orange leader begin to crumble when their paychecks don’t go as far as they did under the previous administration?
The promises made by Trump and his allies during the campaign are already being broken. Trump has already hedged about lowering grocery prices, saying how hard it would be to accomplish what he swore he would do. Co-president Elon Musk has announced that, well, maybe he won’t be able to reduce the deficit by $2 trillion; maybe it’ll just be around $1 trillion (which means, of course, that he’ll shave a few hundred thousand here and there off the deficit and then claim victory).
I doubt that Trump’s sentencing in the New York election interference case1 will change anyone’s mind. All the damaging information has been available for months. It’s “baked in.”
But what about new information that will be revealed by the release of Jack Smith’s reports in the January 6 insurrection investigation and in the Mar-a-Lago classified documents investigation? Is that baked in, too?
My sense is that the only way his most ardent supporters will start to express doubt is if Trump’s actions affect them directly.
We’ve already witnessed some outrage from Trump voters who are only now realizing that getting rid of Obamacare is going to hurt them because they receive their medical care under the Affordable Care Act. (They’re just now making the connection that Obamacare and the ACA are one and the same.)
What happens when co-President Musk starts tampering with Social Security and Medicare?
What about new military interventions in which Americans lose their lives?
What happens if a new pandemic spreads out of control because the Secretary of Health and Human Services is an anti-vaxxer?
Will the stark realities of mass deportation of immigrants trigger pangs of actual conscience among those performative Christians who wave their supposed religiosity in our faces at every turn?
What happens when Wall Street stops betting on the exuberance created by Trump’s promises and start dealing with the reality of the results of his policies? Economic downturns affect everyone, including Trump supporters.
The horrific fires in Los Angeles remind us how important the federal government is, not only in dealing with climate change but also in major assistance with disaster recovery. When the singularly unqualified Kristi Noem is responsible for overseeing FEMA and managing recovery from a disaster of such scope, are his cultists still going to be so thrilled with Trump? After all, fires, floods, hurricanes, landslides, and tornadoes don’t know the difference between Democrats and Republicans.
What happens when the misery proposed by Project 2025 affects everyone, and not just the folks who Trump considers as enemies?
How many more Rudy Giulianis are there left in Trump’s corner — people who are willing to bet (and lose) it all in their zeal to remain in Trump’s good graces?
Will there finally be a point with GOP Senators and Representatives when their constituents become sufficiently disillusioned to take action to stop the long slow march toward autocracy? Will Trump’s second term collapse under the weight of his cruelty, his incompetence, and his indifference toward his own supporters?
I realize this post contains far more questions than answers. The purpose of all those questions is to point out just how many mines there are in the minefield of Trump’s second term — mines that he himself has planted.
The Access Hollywood tape wasn’t enough. Two impeachments weren’t enough. A systematic and widespread effort to suppress opposition votes wasn’t enough. A violent insurrection wasn’t enough. Theft of classified documents wasn’t enough. Thirty-four felony convictions weren’t enough.
But the difference between an autocratic state and a return to some semblance of our democracy is merely that 1.5% electoral margin. Surely the support of at least some of those folks who were all in for Trump will wane.
It’s up to the rest of us to make sure that we remain active in whatever way we can. We have the ability to tip the balance back in the other direction.
I refuse to refer to it as “the hush money case” or “the Stormy Daniels case” the way our mainstream media do, because he paid money to suppress damaging information that would have jeopardized his chances at winning the 2016 election.


