Jack Smith was everyone’s last hope.
In the months leading up to the presidential election, there was still enough room for a glimmer of optimism that Trump would at last face some consequences. Through all the progress and the setbacks of his criminal investigations, Smith seemed to remain quietly undaunted. Certainly someone who had withstood the insults, the public pressure, the threats would have another trick or two up his sleeve.
Smith, after all, had made his name prosecuting despots and war criminals in the International Criminal Court. Surely he would be able to put this third rate tin-pot dictator wannabe behind bars. And even if Smith didn’t prevail in all of the cases, there were so many crimes that his investigations were digging into that at least some of them would inevitably end with convictions.
Jack Smith became the white knight who would charge in on his prosecutorial steed to rescue our legal system and our democracy.
All that was before November 5, 2024.
Since Election Day, we knew this day of reckoning would be coming. We didn’t know exactly what form it would take: Would it be before the end of Biden’s term as President? Would Smith forge ahead with his investigations into the next administration?
With Donald Trump returning to the White House, it has gradually been sinking in that Smith wouldn’t be able to proceed with the federal cases — the classified documents case, and the election interference case in Georgia along side the D.C. insurrection case — because of the 2000 rule implemented by the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC), the entity that provides legal advice to the Department of Justice.
That rule forbids the prosecution of a sitting president, on the premise that such a prosecution would impede a president’s ability to carry out the duties of his or her role.
Because Smith was unable to proceed due to this DOJ rule, he was left with only two options, neither of which is particularly satisfying:
He could continue with the prosecution, even into the next administration, with no guarantee of completion.
He could bring the prosecution to a logical stopping point, and issue a report on the findings to date, and submit his resignation before the end of the Biden administration.
He chose the latter of the two: the marginally less bad option.
And, just like that, the prosecutions are terminated and hopes are dashed once again. As the New York Times reported:
Hours after Mr. Smith submitted his requests, Judge Tanya S. Chutkan, who is overseeing the election interference case in Washington, issued a brief order dismissing the proceeding.
If Smith had chosen the first option, the likelihood of Trump firing him and making sure that any details of the prosecution never saw the light of day was somewhere in the vicinity of 99.999%.
Jack Smith has made it plain that wrapping up these prosecutions is not in any way to be considered an exoneration of Donald Trump and that, in a different political landscape, he would have taken the cases to trial, confident of convictions. (It wasn’t so many months ago that pundits and legal experts were assuring us that the so-called “documents case” in particular was so cut and dried, the evidence so incontrovertible, that a conviction was all but inevitable.)
As with all federal prosecutions that are halted for one reason or another, Smith is required to issue the completed report on the prosecution to the current Attorney General, Merrick Garland. Whether Garland will make that report public is still an open question. Garland has previously made such reports for other cases public. If ever the public had a right to know the details of the suspected criminal activity of an elected official, this would be that time.
But Merrick Garland isn’t Jack Smith. His past behavior has been overly cautious. In fact, had he not waited two years to appoint Jack Smith as special counsel, the cases might very well have ended with convictions by now and we wouldn’t be looking down the barrel of a second Trump term.
Sections of the report pertaining to the classified documents case are likely to be heavily redacted because the prosecution is going forward for Trump’s two co-defendants — Waltine Nauta and Carlos de Oliviera. Of course, if past is prologue, document redaction to protect the prosecution of those co-defendants may become a moot point because Trump is likely to issue pardons for them, thus knee-capping any further prosecution.
There are more specifics about the charges in the various cases in “The Syndicate” — my ongoing effort to track all the crimes of Trump and the people in his orbit.
Not surprisingly, Trump is already gloating on his social media platform, claiming that he has won against all odds. Like all his other criminal activity, he will undoubtedly claim that he has been exonerated when, in truth, he has merely evaded the consequences of his actions by manipulating the legal system in ways that no other citizen has access to.
Lather, rinse, repeat.



So well write /said: “he has merely evaded the consequences of his actions by manipulating the legal system in ways that no other citizen has access to”
Sad but true commentary on MurKKKa