
In his book, “On Tyranny: Twenty Lessons from the Twentieth Century,” historian and scholar Timothy Snyder provides straightforward guidance for subverting authoritarianism. The first lesson in Snyder’s primer is not to willingly cede personal power to a would-be tyrant:
1
Do not obey in advance.
Most of the power of authoritarianism is freely given. In times like these, individuals think ahead about what a more repressive government will want, and then offer themselves without being asked. A citizen who adapts in this way is teaching power what it can do.
— Timothy Snyder, “On Tyranny”
But it seems that MSNBC hosts Joe Scarborough and Mika Brzezinski could hardly wait to make their pilgrimage to Palm Beach to kiss the ring of Donald Trump after his win in the Presidential election.
The couple has been a fixture of morning political chat television. But their return visit to Mar-a-Lago this past Friday is in complete contrast to their increasingly outspoken criticism of Trump over the past 7 years.
Prior to that, of course, Donald Trump was a regular guest and ratings winner on “Morning Joe.” He received untold amount of unpaid and unfettered airtime to spread his propaganda on their air prior to the 2016 election. There are even some who attribute Trump’s win in 2016 to his relentless appearances on Morning Joe.
Here’s a partial transcript of Joe and Mika’s carefully scripted announcement of their visit with Trump last week:
Mika: “On Friday … Joe and I went to Mar-a-Lago to meet personally with President Elect Trump. It was the first time we have seen him in seven years.”
Joe: “Now, we talked about a lot of issues, including abortion, mass deportation, threats of political retribution against political opponents and media outlets. We talked about that a good bit. And it’s gonna come as no surprise to anybody who watches this show, has watched it over the past year or over the past decade that we didn’t see eye-to-eye on a lot of issues and we told him so.”
Mika: “What we did agree on was to restart communications. My father [Former National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski] often spoke with world leaders with whom he and the United States profoundly disagreed. That’s a task shared by reporters and commentators alike. We have not spoken with President Trump since March of 2020, other than a personal call that Joe made to Trump on the morning after the attempt on his life in Butler, Pennsylvania. In this meeting, President Trump was cheerful, he was upbeat, he seemed interested in finding common ground with Democrats on some of the most divisive issues. And for those asking why we would go speak to the President Elect during such fraught times, especially between us, I guess I would ask back, why wouldn’t we?”
— Morning Joe, Nov. 18, 2024
“Why wouldn’t we?” I guess the decades of being D.C. insiders have obfuscated the difference between journalism and diplomacy. Mika compares her fourth estate role to that of her father’s role in government, when the two roles serve entirely different functions and objectives.
As they’ve done in the past, the pair will be using access as a way to report on the things he says, as if he hasn’t repeatedly demonstrated that his word means nothing. But their own colleague Rachel Maddow often reminds us, “Watch what they do, not what they say.”
From the beginning of his real estate days, Trump has made a career by telling people exactly what they wanted to hear. He has a decades-long track record for being a pathological liar. If the Morning Joe power couple want to remain objective in their roles as broadcasters, they don’t achieve that aspiration by placing themselves in the direct line of fire of Trump’s sales pitches.
This on-again/off-again relationship between Trump and the Scarborough-Brzezinski duo is now well over a decade old. But I guess they’re what euphemistically used to be called “slow learners.” It’s astonishing that they could somehow think that it’ll be different this time.
Mika and Joe had to come up with some rationale, some pretense, to justify their bowing down once again to Trump, but pretending it had something to do with journalistic standards is a pretty lame (and transparent) way to do it.
The blowback has been swift and severe, and rightfully so, from competitors and colleagues alike. Rather than cozying up to Trump, they could use their considerable media clout to highlight the ways that the nation can mitigate the damage that Trump has boasted he will do. But they chose the easy path — play the insider game to get access to people in power in some misguided attempt to achieve a better audience share.
It’s been widely reported that ratings for MSNBC generally and for Morning Joe in particular have plummeted since the election. It seems clear that Joe and Mika thought the remedy to that was “more Trump” when, as a purely practical matter, until now, they’ve been developing their core audience of viewers who have done everything in their power to ensure the nation had less Trump.
It’s hard to determine the rationale for this shift. After years of excoriating Trump, do they really think they’re somehow going to siphon viewers away from Fox “News”? Did they think they could hold onto their existing viewership despite their mercurial attitude toward Trump? More importantly, do they stand for anything?


