Friday, January 3, 2025 is a day to watch.
Mike Johnson has been the toadiest of toadies, bowing to virtually every whim of Donald Trump and advancing the MAGA agenda unquestioningly. He has attempted to justify horrific policy positions with a robotic tone befitting one of those voice response systems you’re forced to interact with when you call an airline or a credit card company. During his time as Speaker, he has been the perfect little water carrier for Trump’s shadow presidency.
Yet somehow, that unflinching loyalty is still not enough for some of the most extreme Republicans. There has been chatter for several weeks about whether Johnson has enough support within his own party to hold onto his speakership. The mere fact that Johnson barely managed to eke out a deal to keep the government functioning apparently rubbed some of the destructionist chaos agents the wrong way.
Trump’s trademark lack of clarity, his inarticulateness poorly disguised as approachability, and his frequent changes of positions have created an atmosphere that has enabled each supporter to fabricate an individualized version of what he stands for.
That might be a viable tactic to trick voters into voting for you. But what happens when Trump’s fluidly-held beliefs confuse and alienate the politicians he needs to support him?
Creating an amorphous blob of policy positions may have reeled in gullible voters. But when you place that same amorphous blob in front of people like Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY) and Rep. Andy Biggs (R-AZ), they merely interpret Trump’s promises in a way that aligns their own personal agendas. Then, when it turns out not to match their own agendas exactly, and Trump flip-flops on his “promises,” they threaten to punish him — and the nation — by holding hostage the Speakership of his most powerful ally in Congress.
Should Mike Johnson not receive the required number of votes on January 3 to keep his position as Speaker, it could set off a chain of events that will grind our government to a halt.
Without a duly elected Speaker, elected members of the House of Representatives cannot be seated. Without the House seated, the Presidential election cannot be certified on … what’s that date? … uh, let me think … oh, yes … on January 6th. Without the certification of the election, the President cannot be sworn in.
There are already rumblings among Republicans floating the assertion that we don’t really need a Speaker for the election to be certified. That premise is flimsy, at best. But even if the Republicans were to figure out a way to circumvent the election of a Speaker to swear in all the representatives-elect, it’s the sitting Vice President who must do the actual certification of the election and, in a twist worthy of a daytime soap opera, the sitting Vice President just happens to be the newly re-elected President’s opponent in the election.
So what happens next? Will any of these scenarios play out? Are there enough Republican representatives-elect willing to throw a monkey wrench into the works by trying to oust Speaker Mike Johnson? Will the choosing of a Speaker require 15 or more votes and weeks of public Republican infighting, the way it did with the last battle for the Speakership? Will the failure to choose a Speaker in a timely manner delay the certification of the election and even the Inauguration? Will Republicans force the issue and attempt to corner Vice President Harris into certifying the election without the Representatives being duly sworn in?
As with most things these days, there’s so much we don’t know.
But one thing we do know is that the bedlam created by the Republican Party has nothing to do with providing good governance. As a purely practical matter, it doesn’t even do anything to advance their own extremist political agenda. It’s merely another indication of the bumbling ineptness that permeates today’s Republican Party.
The silver lining in all of this, if there is one, is that the public display of MAGA incompetence benefits Democrats. All the Democrats have to do is sit back and watch the spectacle.


