As we approach Inauguration Day, it’s worth remembering one of the primary reasons why we are where we are: Russia.
“I was exonerated! Russia, Russia, Russia was a hoax,” Donald Trump has spewed indignantly at every opportunity. Nothing could be further from the truth. Russian meddling in our elections is a multi-decade project that has used a multi-pronged approach.
Whether you believe that Trump was involved or not, it’s beholden on the United States to take action. Here are the only two possibilities:
Trump is a covert Russian asset — We’d better do something about Russian election meddling because it’s a threat to our security and our democracy.
Trump is not a covert Russian asset — We’d better do something about Russian election meddling because it’s a threat to our security and our democracy.
A weakened United States is an asset for Putin. It’s virtually impossible to make the case that Trump hasn’t benefitted from the actions taken by Russia. Conversely, it’s easy to make the case that Trump hasn’t done much to prevent Russian meddling. Trump benefits from Russian interference, whether it’s a coordinated effort or not.
Heading into a second “reign of Trump,” it’s important to understand the extent to which Vladimir Putin and Russia have gone to influence U.S. politics. In at least the last three U.S. presidential elections, Russia has played a significant part.
2016 Election
Trump long ago declared himself free of guilt in the 2016 election, despite damning evidence gathered during the Independent Counsel’s investigation and articulated in the Mueller Report. He has repeatedly mocked people who have dared to address Russia’s involvement in U.S. politics.
Yet, while the Mueller Report did not reach a definitive conclusion about Trump’s potential collusion with the Russians, the report was clear about the effects that Russian interference had on the election.
Russian interference in the 2016 election was “sweeping and systemic.”
Major attack avenues included a social media “information warfare” campaign that “favored” candidate Trump and the hacking of Clinton campaign-related databases and release of stolen materials through Russian-created entities and Wikileaks.
Russia also targeted databases in many states related to administering elections gaining access to information for millions of registered voters.
— American Constitution Society, “Key Findings of the Mueller Report”
We’ll probably never know exactly how many voters in 2016 were swayed to vote in favor of Trump or against Hillary Clinton as a direct result of Russia’s actions. Additionally, Russia wasn’t the only factor at play in 2016. But the margin of Trump’s victory was so narrow that it’s quite plausible that the outcome of the election might have been different were it not for the Russian attempts at subverting the election results.
2020 Election
Russian efforts to interfere with United States elections began long before the 2016 election and they continue to this day. By the 2020 election, there was somewhat more awareness of Russian meddling, and there were somewhat better U.S. defenses in place.
But the decades-long effort on the part of Russia didn’t let up.
In August 2020, U.S. counterintelligence chief William Evanina identified [Andrei] Derkach as a key participant in Russian efforts to harm Joe Biden's candidacy in the 2020 U.S. presidential election. United States intelligence community analysis released in March 2021 found that Derkach was among proxies of Russian intelligence who promoted and laundered misleading or unsubstantiated narratives about Biden “to US media organizations, US officials, and prominent US individuals, including some close to former President Trump and his administration.” Trump's personal attorney Rudy Giuliani met with Derkach in December 2019.
Derkach was indicted on a variety of charges in 2022.
Social media disinformation campaigns continued in full force. Side by side with that effort, attacks on election infrastructure continued, with Microsoft citing thousands of attempted attacks that were consistent with the technology profile of the Russian hacking attempts of 2016 and 2018.
2024 Election
Perhaps Americans (or, more likely, American media) have become so numb to foreign influence in our elections that it has become normalized. Consequently, the Department of Justice indictments of multiple Russian nationals for a variety of charges have gone mostly unnoticed.
But that doesn’t mean they didn’t happen. Eight Russian operatives have been indicted for crimes related to 2024 election interference, with charges that include:
Conspiracy to Violate the Foreign Agents Registration Act
Conspiracy to Commit Money Laundering (for channeling $10 million to U.S. companies to spread Russian propaganda re. 2024 U.S. election via social media)
Conspiracy to Commit Computer Intrusion and Damage
Wire Fraud Conspiracy
(The list of the individuals and their charges is available in the table in “The Syndicate.” You can locate the details for each of these individuals by entering foreign 2024 in the Search box at the top of the table. Details for the other Russian indictments are included in the table, as well.)
We’d be naive to think, simply because a few people have been identified and indicted, that the problem of Russia interfering with our elections is solved. Interference by foreign nationals isn’t the only worrisome thing related to Russia in the 2024 Election.
It has been reported recently that tech bro and Trump bestie Elon Musk has been in regular contact by telephone with Vladimir Putin for at least two years.
Even since Election Day, it’s already been reported that Trump himself has had phone calls on unsecured phone lines with Vladimir Putin. That’s not only a serious security risk, it’s likely in violation of federal law:
“Any citizen of the United States, wherever he may be, who, without authority of the United States, directly or indirectly commences or carries on any correspondence or intercourse with any foreign government or any officer or agent thereof, with intent to influence the measures or conduct of any foreign government or of any officer or agent thereof, in relation to any disputes or controversies with the United States, or to defeat the measures of the United States, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both.”
Let’s be clear: Donald Trump is not the President. Until January 20, 2025, he is a private citizen and, therefore, prohibited from carrying on diplomatic relations with other countries — in essence, operating as a shadow government of the United States.
Virtually every prediction I’ve made about Donald Trump has been wrong. “Oh, he’ll drop out of the 2016 primary.” Wrong. “Oh, he’ll never win the nomination.” Wrong. “He’s a joke. He’ll never become president.” Wrong. “People know what he’s like now. He’ll never win the White House again.” Oh, so painfully wrong.
But I’m going to make one prediction that I’m pretty sure won’t be wrong: We have not seen or heard the last of the association between Trump and Russia, and that association is not going to be one that’s in the best interest of our democracy.
I wouldn’t hesitate to put money on that.


