Since Nov. 5, Democrats have appeared to be in a persistent state of shock. There’s been an abundance of wound-licking and navel-gazing. There’s been a profusion of finger-pointing and ample evidence of an ongoing circular firing squad. There have been reports of meetings in which party leaders are discussing changes to Democratic strategy.
One thing I haven't read about is any plans for Democrats to go on the offensive. That is surprising, considering that the Democrats probably have more ammunition to fire at the GOP than at any time in recent history, and perhaps more than at any time in either party’s history.
The Republicans put forward an adjudicated rapist and convicted felon as their candidate, an advocate for autocracy, who somehow won the election and now has nominated the biggest gaggle of crooks and weirdos and other assorted miscreants as his cabinet.
Yet, more than a month after the election, the Democrats (and consequently the news media) are still talking about what Democrats did wrong.
You know what the Democrats have done wrong? I’ll boil it down to five words: They’ve been too damn polite.
Former Republican politicians are doing a better job at pushing back on Republicans than our Democratic politicians. January 6 Committee members Adam Kinzinger and Liz Cheney, whose views on policy and governance are far from those of the Democrats, are standing up to the bullies who have directly threatened their lives and their freedom. Less well known but equally outspoken is David Jolly, the former GOP Representative from Florida. Having left or been squeezed out of their political careers, they have nothing to lose (unless you count their lives at the hands of MAGA extremists).
Current and former Democratic politicians could learn a lesson or two from them.
There are, of course, some notable exceptions within the Democratic Party:
There probably couldn't be a better choice for minority leader than Hakeem Jeffries. He has been extremely outspoken and straightforward in his role while still maintaining the decorum befitting his office and protecting his future political chances. The Democrats will be lucky to have him as Speaker when the political tides turn.
Jasmine Crockett (D-TX), a junior member of the Oversight Committee, has quickly built a reputation as a bit of a firebrand, holding people’s feet to the fire in committee hearings and on the floor of the House. She comes to committee hearings armed with facts, and she doesn’t easily retreat from conflict.
I'll be paying close attention to Pete Buttigieg, the current Secretary of Transportation, once he no longer has the legal constraints of being a member of a presidential administration. Even in his position in the White House, he has been able to make a strong case for Democratic policies, positions, and accomplishments, without crossing the legal lines of campaigning from his office. He’s also become known not to flinch from going into the “enemy territory” of Fox News to inject some truth serum into their broadcasts.
What do these three have in common, aside from their determination to champion progressive and liberal concerns? Each is a member of a minority and, as such, each has directly felt the consequences of bad and discriminatory policy choices. In their individual ways, they each have a fire in their bellies that impel them to action. Through life experience, they have had to learn how to advocate for themselves and for others. A measure of activism seems to run quietly — and sometimes loudly — through their veins.
Some of the more complacent, conflict-averse white cisgender members of the Democratic Party could learn a lesson from these colleagues as well, particularly in this era in which Republicans have taken a no-holds-barred approach to governance. Career Democratic Congresspeople will need to disabuse themselves of the notion that our way of life can survive without them sticking their necks out a little. Until they do, there will always be an imbalance between the two major political parties.
I want to believe, in the interregnum between the sanity and stability of the Biden administration and the inevitable insanity and instability of the next administration, that the Democrats have been formulating a cohesive plan to deal with what’s next and that they’ve been working to get buy-in from all corners of the party.
I want to believe that the relative quiet is indicative of the party taking a nose-to-the-grindstone approach to tackling the incoming autocratic beast.
I want to believe that the party has done contingency planning for every conceivable eventuality.
I want to believe that the party also has learned to be nimble enough to respond effectively to any curve balls that are thrown their way, because there will be many.
I want to believe that Democrats’ fear of retribution has been overpowered by the courage of their convictions.
Of course, we won't know fully what the Democratic strategy is (if indeed there is one) until Congress is in session. We'll witness it in all its glory or all its timidity during the Senate confirmation hearings for Cabinet positions. We'll see it in the Appropriations Committee in the House when some of the proposed draconian cuts are presented to them.
We’ll initially be able to measure its success, at least in part, by the number of unqualified nominees who are blocked and by the fervor with which Democratic Senators put each nominee’s dirty laundry on full display. Let’s hope they do just that. They owe it to the majority of Americans who still want to live in a democracy.


