I don’t usually start my posts with a disclaimer, but it somehow seems necessary, considering the subject matter. I do not advocate violence as an activism strategy. I deplore the fact that someone has shot and killed Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare, in what appears to be a pre-meditated targeted killing.
That said, given the current environment of a country that turns a blind eye to gun violence (at least legislatively) coupled with a healthcare system that clearly puts profits first and often leaves patients out in the cold or bankrupt, it isn’t surprising that such a killing has occurred.
The cold-blooded murder of an American healthcare executive has become the media’s latest shiny object, redirecting the nation’s attention from the previous media shiny object, the pardon of Hunter Biden. But, similar to the Hunter Biden story, there’s been little more than surface-level analysis of the political and societal reasons for either of these events.
With the Biden pardon, the media have been collectively wringing their hands about President Biden going back on his word that there would be no such pardon, while entirely ignoring that there have been unprecedented and likely illegal threats of vengeance on the part of the incoming president and his nominees, with Hunter Biden as only one target of such threats.
In the case of the slaying of Brian Thompson, the focus by the media has been almost completely on the act itself and the attempts at apprehending the killer. That’s defensible, up to a point, particularly in the immediate aftermath of such an event. But there’s been barely a mention of a healthcare system in which health insurance executives can amass hundreds of millions — even billions — of dollars in net worth, and shareholders of health insurers and hospital corporations can profit handsomely, while patients often get the short end of the stick.
(Incidentally, both of these media blind spots are a reflection of the corporatization of our media and the attendant staff reductions in the name of efficiency. A right-leaning bias has replaced journalistic standards. But that’s a whole other story.)
When you purchase health insurance, either directly or through your employer, you’re betting that, at some point, you’re going to need medical care. The insurance companies are stacking the deck to provide the most limited coverage allowable within the law while still turning a profit.
Even if you are independently wealthy, it’s all but impossible to receive medical care without becoming enmeshed in the care-for-profit system that the United States has come to accept as the status quo. In that system, there is always a maze of inflated or even completely unnecessary costs that a patient has to deal with in order to receive care.
The Affordable Care Act — yes, Obamacare — legally mandated that at least 80% of heath insurance premiums go directly to providing medical care. But even that law enables 20% of your premium to become the lifeblood of the health insurance companies. (They like to be referred to as “healthcare corporations” these days, but that’s mostly a façade. Their primary reason for existence is not to provide medical care but rather to derive profit from the premiums you pay.)
Given the nature of corporations, you can be assured that teams of highly paid attorneys and CPAs are also perpetually on the lookout for any legal and financial loopholes to the ACA that will maximize their profits.
When you pay your premium, the overhead that’s involved is staggering. Here’s a partial list of the accounting buckets your premium gets divided into that don’t contribute directly to your medical care:
Executive compensation — Salaries, bonuses, stock options often run into multiples of millions of dollars yearly. The finger rightfully gets pointed at these often excessive pay packages, but they’re not the only culprit or, perhaps, not even the worst culprit.
Claims processing — When you or your provider submit a claim for services, instead of just paying the standard amount that has been authorized for those services, the claim goes through a clearinghouse that analyzes it for accurate coding and derives statistics that help the insurer optimize profits.
Claims adjudication — Part of your monthly premium every month goes toward supporting an organizational structure that is designed to figure out ways to deny your coverage. (Denial rates have been as high as 49%.)
Plan development/product development — Health insurers design coverage plans that are meant to entice companies and individuals to purchase them while simultaneously competing with other health insurers who are doing the same thing. Teams of employees work to create the most appealing sounding products that will provide coverage to insureds but will still maximize their profits.
Provider networks — Part of product development is the creation of groups of medical providers who are willing to provide services for the pre-determined amounts that are set by the health insurance companies. Changes in these networks from one calendar year to the next often mean that a provider you have one year may be out-of-network the next year. Continuity of care isn’t of particular importance to health insurance companies; providers are assumed to be interchangeable, and doctor-patient relationships are hard to come by.
Marketing — Marketing teams spend millions to convince companies and individuals to choose their plans over the plans of other health healthcare insurers.
IT infrastructure — IT professionals are needed for billing systems, accounting systems, EOBs, member management, member communication, and all sorts of other functions. These systems are in a constant state of being updated to accommodate changes in plans, networks, and marketing efforts.
Actuaries — Actuaries evaluate risk to ensure that more money is coming into the health insurers’ accounts than is being paid out to members.
PBMs (Pharmacy Benefit Managers) — These third-party entities put together formularies (lists of drugs) that will be covered by health insurance plans. Such PBM plans often supersede a medical professional’s judgment as to which medication is best for a particular patient’s condition.
Public relations — As you might guess, these companies need
double-talkpublic relations experts to explain away lawsuits and keep the media on their side.Shareholder dividends and stock price increases — It’s American capitalism in the 21st century, so after all those other folks are paid, the first obligation of health insurance companies — like other publicly traded companies — is to their shareholders. A health insurance executive who doesn’t perform well on Wall Street on behalf of his or her company doesn’t have a job for long. But even when they lose their jobs, they’re likely to exit with huge severance packages.
Oh, wait. There’s one more thing they’re spending money on these days:
Security — Security details for their executives are becoming more important because these companies’ practices are so universally despised that the people leading them are at risk of losing their lives. I guess they’re discovering they need at least as many barriers between their executives and the general public as they place between their members and their health care providers.
Health insurance companies tend to characterize all that expense as “the cost of doing business.” But you can’t siphon away billions of dollars presumably being paid for medical care to pay for all these other often questionable functions and expect the nation to have a healthcare system that meets the needs of its citizens. This is not a model that centers around the patient’s best interests.
One thing is clear. If we were starting from scratch to build the absolute best healthcare system for the United States of today, it wouldn’t look anything like our current system.
Here’s a thought: We hear the DOGE bros talking in sweeping generalizations about slashing government to eliminate inefficiencies. Any chance they could apply the same standards to health insurance companies?



I think we can safely say BILLIONS in marketing.. and that's just the health insurance company itself... the amount that the vendors spend is even more obscene. Then also add LOBBYING which is of course marketing to people in power
And to further illustrate how our society works… add up the millions of dollars being spent by police and federal agencies on the manhunt for one guy …considering the countless murders of “nobodies” that go unsolved and un worked