“The Peter principle is a concept in management developed by Laurence J. Peter which observes that people in a hierarchy tend to rise to ‘a level of respective incompetence’: employees are promoted based on their success in previous jobs until they reach a level at which they are no longer competent, as skills in one job do not necessarily translate to another.”
— Wikipedia, based on 1969 book "The Peter Principle" by Laurence Peter and Raymond Hull
To say that Donald Trump is appointing folks who have risen to "a level of respective incompetence" is about the kindest think you could say about the team he is assembling. It seems like everyone he has nominated so far is drastically out of their depth.
We've heard all about the imaginary “deep state” from the MAGA for all these years. I suppose Trump's antidote to that imaginary deep state is the “shallow state.” His cabinet picks and other appointees are evidence of that.
Some of these nominees are merely foolish choices but some are downright dangerous. About the only thing they seem to have in common is their loyalty to Trump. In most cases, they are even less qualified for their roles than Trump is for his.
It was reported this week that the once and future President is foregoing the standard FBI vetting process. That's not surprising. He certainly doesn't want any dirty laundry to be aired publicly before his term starts, although that may be unavoidable.
It has been reported how capricious some of Trump's picks have been:
“President-elect Donald J. Trump chose his attorney general almost on a whim, in the sky between Washington and Palm Beach, Fla. He scoffed at a candidate for the Department of Homeland Security, then abruptly changed his mind. His defense secretary pick was a snap judgment during a slide presentation at Mar-a-Lago.”
But even a surface-level examination of many of these nominees reveals how unqualified they are for the roles they're being nominated for:
Elon Musk
Department of Government Efficiency
No government experience
Previous experience with slashing employees resulted in economic losses: loss of subscribers, loss of advertisers, and loss of integrity.
Major conflicts of interest — government contracts for SpaceX, xAI (Musk's AI startup)
Vivek Ramaswamy
Department of Government Efficiency
No government experience
Promised to slash 75% of the federal workforce when he was a candidate for president
Matt Gaetz
Attorney General
Subject of investigation by House Ethics Committee for sex with underage girl and sex trafficking
Resigned from Congress to avoid release of results of investigation
Reported to have boasted about his underage sexual conquests to colleagues on the floor of the House
Security Risk
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
Director, Health and Human Services
No background in medicine or science
Has perpetuated disproven conspiracy theories about vaccines
Had a worm in his brain
Hauled a dead bear from the countryside to Central Park for a photo op
Opposed by most members of his family, on whose name he rose to prominence
Tulsi Gabbard
Director of National Intelligence
Consorted with Bashar al Assad and denied he is an enemy of the US
Has knowingly spread Russian propaganda
Member of extreme right wing religious cult
Decades-long experience in virulently anti-LGBTQ activism
Security risk
Kristi Noem
Director, Department of Homeland Security
No relevant experience
No experience leading complex, massive organization (260,000 employees)
Banned from the land of all nine Native American tribes within her state
Elise Stefanik
U.N. Ambassador
No diplomatic experience
No diplomacy
Election denier in 2020
Used racist “great replacement theory” as a talking point in her re-election campaign
Stephen Cheung
Director of Communications
Former spokesman for Ultimate Fighting Championship
Accused Arlington National Cemetery worker of "having a mental health episode" for having asked Trump not to take pictures in the cemetery, in accordance with federal law
The above is far from a complete list of the less-than-stellar nominees nor does that list begin to include all the negative aspects of those who are on it. But just a cursory examination of their credentials would indicate that the Peter principle has gone into overdrive with this collection of nominees.
Trump has a reputation for having been disengaged during his first term. The people around him had to trick him into dealing with the urgent matters of the day. But at least those people were around him.
This current crop of toadies, sycophants, and other assorted miscreants doesn’t seem to possess the wherewithal to guide Trump in the general right direction. It can also be argued that many of them have interests of their own that they want moved forward; loyalty to the Constitution and adherence to the rule of law are likely secondary to their own interests.
Time will tell whether there are any Republicans in the Senate who have sufficient courage to stand up to Trump. Will any of them risk provoking Trump’s wrath? The track record among Republicans isn’t a good omen.


