
Trump announced earlier this week that he’d be creating a weird non-governmental government agency — the “Department of Government Efficiency” or DOGE — to be headed by Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy. This should come as no surprise. Musk has been touting this (until now) imaginary department on X/Twitter for some time and, as recently as the beginning of this month, he has been quoted as saying that, should Trump win re-election, that Americans should expect “temporary hardship” from the massive economic downturn his cuts would cause.
That seems like a bit of an understatement. Musk and Trump are proposing $2 trillion in cuts — roughly a third of the nation’s annual budget:
Musk suggested that this budget cutting — combined with Trump’s mass deportation plan — would cause a market-crashing economic “storm.”
On his social media platform, X (a.k.a. Twitter), an anonymous user posted Tuesday that, “If Trump succeeds in forcing through mass deportations, combined with Elon hacking away at the government, firing people and reducing the deficit - there will be an initial severe overreaction in the economy…Market will tumble. But when the storm passes and everyone realizes we are on sounder footing, there will be a rapid recovery to a healthier, sustainable economy.”
Musk replied, “Sounds about right.”
Ronald Reagan famously set the tone for this slash-and-burn madness at a 1986 news conference:
I think you all know that I've always felt the nine most terrifying words in the English language are: “I'm from the Government, and I'm here to help.”
— Ronald Reagan, August 12, 1986
Reagan’s disciples conveniently overlook the millions of citizens who are protected by or otherwise benefit from government programs and entities like Social Security, Medicare, OSHA, FEMA, the National Weather Service, the Department of Veterans Affairs, and the FAA (to name just a few).
They also ignore or forget about institutional knowledge — the years of experience and know-how that federal employees accrue in their service to the government. If Musk and Ramaswamy are given carte blanche to start dismantling government agencies to save a few dollars, they’ll also be throwing away decades of institutional knowledge that we can’t put a price tag on.
You might think that Musk would be a little more cautious considering his own experience tossing aside Twitter’s institutional knowledge. His own recent history with cost-cutting isn’t exactly his best selling point. Prior to Musk’s $44 billion dollar purchase of Twitter, the platform wasn’t profitable overall, although it did have a couple of years of profitability.
But when Musk purchased the platform in 2022, in some misguided attempt to fix the company’s finances, he gutted the workforce firing many of the engineers who had been keeping the platform functioning. Top executives fled. Content moderators — the people who attempted to keep the platform safe and truthful — were also fired. By November of that same year, a mere 6 months later, Musk was warning of bankruptcy.
What remains of Twitter (now X) is a cesspool of right-wing hate speech, misinformation, and agitprop. Many stalwart end users, repulsed by the overall tone of X, have been deactivating and closing their accounts. As a result, advertisers — the only source of revenue — started to abandon the platform. As recently as this week, more and more of the remaining advertisers have made public announcements distancing themselves from X. Musk has even sued some of the advertisers who abandoned the platform, desperate to save face.
So what, exactly, are Musk’s qualifications for this new role? Did the fact that Musk gave Trump’s campaign $75 million (plus untold amounts of free media on his social media platform) enter into Trump’s decision to form a new department of some weird parallel government structure?
The premise of treating the federal government like it’s one of Trump’s or Musk’s or Ramaswamy’s businesses is faulty. The U.S. government is not a business. The government exists to serve and protect its citizens.
During his failed bid for the Presidency, Vivek Ramaswamy regularly claimed that he would cut 75% of the federal workforce. Not only was the premise idiotic back then, because our government pretty much would have ceased to function, but those cuts also wouldn’t have achieved their budget-cutting objectives.
If every federal employee in all departments and federal agencies were laid off, the total amount saved would be a fraction of the $2 trillion that Musk and Ramaswamy and Trump have proposed.
In truth, there are most certainly efficiencies that can be realized within the federal government. An organization with three million employees should be in a regular cycle of self-examination and continuous improvement. But coming in with a bulldozer and knocking out the foundations of the departments and agencies that literally and figuratively keep the nation’s lights on is a recipe for disaster.
But if left to their own devices, Musk and Ramaswamy will do to the federal government what Melania did to the White House Rose Garden.



“If every federal employee in all departments and federal agencies were laid off, the total amount saved would be a fraction of the $2 trillion that Musk and Ramaswamy and Trump have proposed.”💯